Saint Matthew student athletes have created a cross country legacy. The varsity girls and the varsity boys teams have won 12 diocesan championships, including the eighth straight girls championships. The girls placed in the top 20 in the state five times since 2009. The boys placed in the top 10 in the state three times since 2011. Since 2011, 9 students have finished in the top 20 in the state individuals.
Under direction of Coach Libby Crow (Vanderbilt Commodore '88) junior varsity and varsity basketball teams have won 8 parochial league championships. Soccer teams have won the trophy three times, most recently in 2011.
In 2012, junior varsity volleyball, varsity volleyball and golf teams all brought home the championship trophy.